This blog helps retail marketers understand how to balance AI with human creativity, the top challenge identified in the AI and the Future of the Retail Marketer report, published by Total Retail in partnership with Optimove.
Ninety-four percent (94%) of retailer marketers already use AI, and 95% say it has changed their role. The real test is how to integrate AI without losing the human touch – a delicate balance key to scaling personalized campaigns.
Stay in touch
Be the first to know all about the latest Marketing tips & tricks, Industry special insights and more
Key Takeaways
AI adoption is universal: 94% of retailers already use AI in marketing, making it a baseline requirement, not a differentiator
Marketers are transforming: 95% say AI has changed their role, expanding responsibilities beyond fixed roles in assembly-line marketing
Balance is the hardest part: 54% of retailers cite balancing automation with human interaction as their top struggle, ahead of privacy, data quality, and cost
The payoff is significant: Retailers who achieve this balance report 78% efficiency gains, 63% higher customer lifetime value, and measurable growth in revenue, conversions, and cost savings
AI Adoption Is Only the Beginning
Artificial intelligence has moved past experimentation and into the core of retail marketing. The report, “AI and the Future of the Retail Marketer,” published by Total Retail in partnership with Optimove, reveals a striking reality: 94% of retailers already use AI in their marketing, and 95% of marketers say it has fundamentally changed their role.
Now the challenge is no longer adoption. It is deciding where automation should drive efficiency and where humans should control the marketing process to ensure creativity, empathy, and a consistent brand voice.
How to treat every campaign like a marketing experiment
More than half of retailer marketers (54%) say their biggest struggle is balancing AI automation with human interaction. This ranks above privacy, data quality, and cost, showing how central the human-AI balance has become.
AI excels at processing massive datasets and executing at speed but left alone it can generate campaigns that can run amuck. Humans bring creativity and emotional intelligence yet cannot match AI’s ability to personalize at scale for millions of customers.
The danger lies in leaning too far in either direction. Over-automate, and customers experience robotic, or off-message interactions. Rely too heavily on humans and lose the ability to personalize at scale. The optimum is in mastering balance.
What Happens When You Find the Sweet Spot
Retailer marketers who are making progress in cracking this code see dramatic results. According to the report, 78% of marketers experience improved employee efficiency, 63% report higher customer lifetime value, and more than half see measurable revenue growth, conversion improvements, and cost savings.
These outcomes stem from a simple but powerful approach: AI handles the heavy analytical work while humans oversee marketing campaigns to ensure every customer touchpoint feels authentic and brand-aligned. The result is messages that arrive at precisely the right moment with exactly the right tone.
The Human-AI Harmony Blueprint
The report shows that balance is not just a theory. It translates into concrete practices that high-performing retail brands are already using. Three principles stand out:
AI for Scale: Use AI to analyze data, segment audiences, and automate execution at speed
Humans for Relevant Messages: Keep people at the center of messaging to ensure campaigns connect with consumers that show empathy and build trust
Strategy Together: Let AI surface insights and opportunities, then rely on marketers to frame and guide them into stories and messages that inspire action
At Optimove, this philosophy is captured in Positionless Marketing, where marketers are no longer confined to traditional silos from an antiquated assembly-line system. Instead, they are empowered to combine AI capabilities with human creativity to deliver exceptional customer experiences.
3 Real-World Applications
Here are use cases where the human + AI balance comes to life in retail marketing:
#1. Personalized Email Campaigns – AI spots that a frequent customer has not purchased in 30 days and predicts three products she is most likely to buy. Marketers then build the narrative. Instead of a generic “You might also like…” message, the email becomes “Complete your spring collection,” paired with imagery and copy that match her style and the brand’s voice.
#2. Dynamic Pricing and Promotions – AI detects which customers are price-sensitive and which are not, preventing unnecessary discounts. Marketers then frame the offer that protects brand value. Rather than a blunt “20% off before you leave!” popup, the message becomes “As a loyal customer, enjoy early access to this season’s favorites.”
#3. Cross-Channel Journey Orchestration – AI determines timing, frequency, and channel preference across email, social, and mobile with precision. Human strategists design the narrative arc that connects those touchpoints, so the customer experiences a cohesive story, not a series of isolated pushes.
The Competitive Edge
The marketers mastering this balance are not just improving performance. They are reshaping customer expectations. When a campaign feels both perfectly timed and unmistakably human, it does more than drive a transaction. It builds loyalty that lasts.
This is where Positionless Marketing becomes a true competitive edge. Removing the barriers created by assembly-line marketing between data analysts, creatives, and campaign managers allows teams to move seamlessly from insight to execution, from automation to personalization. The result is marketing that is faster, smarter, and more human at scale.
The Guide to Control Groups in Marketing
Optimize your marketing efforts with our guide and gain access to a free uplift calculator.
As AI capabilities expand and customer expectations rise, the retailer marketers who thrive will be those who ensure that technology and human creativity are complementary. AI provides scale, while humans guide the marketing to ensure the story and soul.
The future belongs to campaigns that feel both highly personal and seamlessly scalable experiences customers remember. That is the hallmark of legendary marketing.
To learn more about Positionless Marketing and make your campaigns legendary, contact us to request a demo.
Rony Vexelman is Optimove’s VP of Marketing. Rony leads Optimove’s marketing strategy across regions and industries. Previously, Rony was Optimove's Director of Product Marketing leading product releases, customer marketing efforts and analyst relations. Rony holds a BA in Business Administration and Sociology from Tel Aviv University and an MBA from UCLA Anderson School of Management.
